in the Humanities and Social Sciences
12th Annual Symposium (May 16, 2009) Abstracts
Grace Christiansen: "1798: Lyrical Ballads in a Malthusian Context"
Stephen Flynn: "Switchers and Sustainers: The Use of Side Issues in the 2008 Financial Bailout Bill"
Jamie Gajewski: "A Bilingual Tour of La Alhambra: The Last Landmark of Al-Andalus"
Since this is a project more so than a paper, the thesis is still evolving and will continue to do so as I prepare it for a grant proposal. However, I would talk about how the project began, how it progressed, and where it is taking me in the future. Currently, the thesis is that la Alhambra serves as the last landmark of a period in which Spain was ruled by Muslims and much like the use of the palace has changed since its acquisition in 1492, so have the attitudes associated with la Alhambra.
I would be presenting my project in Spanish.
Sarah Griebler: "A Study of Personality and Student Participation in College Discussion Classes"
However, past researchers have rarely examined class participation as a dependent measure of academic achievement. For students in college discussion-based classes, their participation grade may account for 15-25% of their final course grade. Therefore, research about how a student’s personality may affect his or her class participation is necessary and important. Unfortunately, the great effort, time, and resources required to record and transcribe class discussions may have discouraged past researchers from studying participation. However, the current study argues that the benefits of recording classes and acquiring discussion transcriptions far outweigh the challenges because of the precise measures of participation we can extract from the transcriptions (i.e., each student’s total word count in a discussion, the exact number of times each student speaks, the content of each contribution, etc.).
Methods. Therefore, the current study analyzed 16 recorded discussions of four Fall 2008 sections of Freshman Studies (discussion topics: Messiaen, Einstein, Plato, and Bishop). The study also administered Oliver John’s (1991) Big Five Inventory, a questionnaire that assesses the five traits in Costa and McCrae’s personality model, to the students in the four sections. 89% of the students in the desired sample filled out the inventory. They also filled out four questionnaires asking them about their discussion experiences, including how they prepared for class, their attitudes towards class participation, their enjoyment of the class, etc.
Results. For the current study, a student’s total word count in the transcribed discussion was treated as a measure of his or her total speaking time during the discussion. A regression analysis showed that together extraversion, openness to experience, and agreeableness account for approximately one-third of the variance in student word count (R2= .304), which is highly significant F(3, 45) = 8.1, p<.001. Extraversion (ß=.303, p=.03), openness to experience (ß=.439, p=.001), and agreeableness (ß=-.431, p=.002) are significant predictors of students’ word counts. Neuroticism and conscientiousness are not predictors of word count.
The study also analyzed non-personality independent variables (gender, diversity, FRST exam grades, FRST course grades, major/minor, hobbies, enjoyment of the class, preparation for class, lecture attendance, etc.), but found that only extraversion, openness to experience, and agreeableness are significant predictors of students’ word counts. For example, we might expect that a student’s degree of preparation predicts how frequently he or she participates in class, but the current study found that preparation is not a significant predictor. The current study’s results suggest that the factors that predict a student’s class participation deserve further study.
Courtney Kleftis: "The Masquerade of Life: Gender, Identity, and Subversive Power in Performance"
Awareness of the performative nature of identity can be empowering. However, due to the element of display involved, the act of performing makes people vulnerable to objectification by their audience. Seventeenth-century Venetian composer Barbara Strozzi’s success was allowable within the male-dominated intellectual circles of her time due the ambiguity of her role. It has been hypothesized that she was a courtesan, which may have provided her with a socially acceptable means of receiving the education and support necessary for success within the male-dominated profession of composition. Strozzi frequently composed and performed music with text which demeaned and objectified women. Continuing to fulfill this traditional female role ensured the continued patronage of her male audience, while her role as both a composer and performer allowed her to subtly mock them.
Within the context of the sexually-repressed society of 1890’s Paris, Claude Debussy composed exceptionally erotic music. His “Trois Chansons de Bilitis,&rdqup; a set of songs based on poetry about the sexual awakening of an ancient Greek girl named Bilitis, is extremely erotic. Ironically, Debussy specifically requested that the young woman who portrayed Bilitis be naïve and incapable of comprehending the blatant sensuality of both his music and the poetry. The sensuality of his music contradicts his documented request for a naïve portrayal of Bilitis, creating a double standard. Manipulation of this double standard provides a means of empowerment for the performer by giving her control over both her sensuality and her male audience.
During the Enlightenment era of late 18th-century Vienna, W.A. Mozart composed the opera Così fan tutte. Its title, “all women are like that,” appears to characterize this opera as a misogynistic diatribe against women. However, the subversive manner in which Mozart composed this opera instead demonstrates his intention to negate these claims. By juxtaposing serious and comic operatic conventions within this work he destabilizes them. Mozart’s character Despina, like Mozart himself, manipulates social conventions in order to survive in an oppressive society.
Like gender roles, musical meaning is fluid and dynamic rather than static and concrete. Awareness of this fluidity empowers individuals to shape their own identities by renegotiating social boundaries and hierarchies which are in constant flux. It is possible to contribute to social progress by actively performing one’s gender identity, both on and off stage. It is, however, important to recognize the responsibility that inherently accompanies the use of such power.
Stephanie Martin: "The Slow Death of Slavery: How Slavery in Massachusetts Ended Socially and Economically but not Legally"
James McDaniel: "Insurrection 1956: Tibetan leaders in Litang and Chatreng"
By examining this piece, we come closer to understanding the political and social maneuvering and pressures Tibetan leaders faced at the time as well as the attitude of the PRC writers of the piece towards those leaders. The language used by the PRC writers harkens back to more traditional Han Chinese ethnographers as they described ethnic groups on the fringes of Chinese territories. Yet, the piece also has a strong flare of communist rhetoric.
Overall, this work helps in its small way to fill in the large dearth of information on modern Tibetan history. With the help of Professor Tsomu, I conducted background research to place the translated piece into a larger context. As the subject of modern Tibet has become extremely controversial, I have taken extra care to be as objective as possible, making it very clear when and where Chinese sources where used as well as Tibetan. With my extended background in Chinese language study as well as my recent acquisition of a rudimentary understanding of Tibetan language, under the tutelage of Professor Tsomu, I feel that I have a unique perspective on the piece and am able to pull from both sides of the conflict, hoping to forge a well constructed history of those leaders in Litang and Chatreng during the 1950s.
Christopher J. McGeorge: "Dickens and Society"
In Oliver Twist, Bleak House and Our Mutual Friend Dickens’s portrayal of the hearth and the system of domesticity that manage it certainly changes. This change in portrayal, however, does not have to constitute a change in the way Dickens views it. What we seem to find is that, rather than critiquing domestic ideology, Dickens supports it. Failed homes and unsatisfying endings are the result not of domestic ideology failing, but of it never being fully instituted or followed. It is for this reason that the Jellyby household is so miserable, why many find the ending to Our Mutual Friend unsatisfying and problematic and why the conclusion of Oliver Twist becomes so idyllic.
Many scholars interpret Dickens’s view of the hearth and domesticity as unstable. However, by examining three novels from different stages in Dickens’s career, Oliver Twist, Bleak House and Our Mutual Friend, we gain a better understanding of how Dickens’s portrayal of the hearth and domesticity changes while his view of it remains static. Determining whether Dickens views the solution of the hearth and domesticity statically or amorphously is important in that it creates the possibility of more concrete scholarly investigations.
Emma Nager: "Rethinking Our Bodies, Ourselves; A Feminist Systems Approach to Body Image, Eating Habits, and Self-Objectification"
Historically, we have understood eating disorders and body image largely as women’s issues. Though the growing body of research on men and body image illuminates an increasing pressure to adhere to masculine ideals of appearance, it has been well documented that Western women’s bodies are looked at, evaluated, and sexualized to a greater degree than are men. This treatment is defined as objectification: the assessment of one’s self-worth by evaluating and comparing physical appearance to sexually objectifying and unrealistic standards of beauty. This paper will review existing literature on sexual objectification of the female body in Western society, and how this treatment may negatively affect women’s mental health.
I will first explore feminist sociocultural theories of the body and how this relates to the predominantly feminine experience of body image and eating issues. These ideas are formalized in objectification theory, developed as a framework for understanding how women’s objectifying experiences are related to negative effects on mental health and life experience . A central tenet of the theory is that objectification influences women and girls to internalize the observer’s perspective of their physical selves, treating themselves as objects to be looked at or evaluated on the basis of appearance. This form of self-objectification often leads to a constant monitoring of physical appearance from the perspective of others, which can serve as a source of shame, anxiety, and negative rumination when one, unsurprisingly, is unable to meet these unrealistic standards. Sexual objectification occurs in a variety of contexts and forms, often contributing to women’s experience of mental health problems – specifically depression, sexual dysfunction, and eating disorders.
It is clear that our modern conceptions of the relationships between women, eating habits and body image deserve a closer examination. Although the media has been long identified as a source of unrealistic standards of physical appearance, the negative emotions stemming from body image issues must be identified individually and examined holistically, acknowledging different sources of objectification and their specific effects on the well-being of women and girls.
John Olson: "Approaching Babi Yar: Intersections of Music, Text, and Genre in Shostakovich’s Thirteenth Symphony"
Secondly, I try to illustrate how Shostakovich’s symphony, and the poems that are set in it, functions as a recovery of two pasts—that of anti-semitism in Russia, and subtextually, the terrible years of the Stalinist purges in the1930s. Taken together, the poems and Shostakovich’s symphony form a monument—the absence of which is remarked upon in the first line of the first poem of the cycle: “Above Babi Yar there are no monuments.” I attempt to illustrate how the music, text, and the genre of the symphony work together to monumentalize and memorialize these two pasts, which had been in many ways deemed irrecoverable by Soviet cultural politics, and what the consequences of such a work are in the Soviet artistic climate of the day.
Kaleesha Rajamantri: "Race, Colonization, and Aboriginal Struggles with the Australian National Referendum"
This paper, while focusing on the Aborigines, is a comparative investigation of the plights of all indigenous peoples. The relevance of the central theme of this paper – discrimination on the basis of race, religion, language, and culture by colonizers – is not restricted to the Aborigines alone. Although it is widely accepted that ethnic discrimination is a fact of our collective history, this is not a justification for colonial offences against indigenous peoples. It is important to scrutinize past mistakes and offences, in order to learn from them, and ensure that such atrocities never repeat themselves.
This paper is unique in that it explores the two possible motivators behind the National Referendum: either Australia genuinely cared about the rights, equality and treatment of their indigenous population, or, Australia voted ‘yes’ in order to salvage their reputation in the eyes of the world. Regardless of their motives, the ends do justify the means. The passing of the referendum unified the population of Australia in its goal to amend its constitution and restore pride to its indigenous population. The combination of these two motivating factors, (caring about their population and fear of having their reputation tarnished) stand as testament that the Aborigines will not be mistreated in the future.
While recognizing that the National Referendum is an important part of Aborigine history, I examine it through a very critical lens. The story of the Australian National Referendum of 1967 is analogous to a children’s fairy tale; a sad story with a happy ending that is not completely accurate, but is nevertheless retold to inspire listeners. This particular story examines how the Aborigines ‘got their rights’, but in reality, the 1967 National Referendum was not that occasion. The National Referendum illustrates struggles faced by indigenous peoples, and helps us better understand the relationship between colonization and racism. Ethnic discrimination is not just an element of our past, but a contemporary global issue, and it is important to bear this in mind, and be sensitive to the issues faced by indigenous peoples today.
Daniel Schirmer: "Feminists and their Ideas about Marriage in Eighteenth Century Conduct Literature"
With the rise of print culture, educated women began to publish more and more, and occasionally they would voice their opinions about marriage through novels, plays, and what were called “conduct books.” Conduct literature was a relatively popular genre of writing in the late seventeenth and eighteenth centuries consisting mainly of moral, social, and religious advice aimed primarily at younger, unmarried women. The content was didactic, and heavily reflective of each writer’s own personal beliefs. The authors would typically lay out a plan for how they thought women should live their lives, occasionally writing in response to other similar, though misogynist tracts by male authors.
In the end, the advice these women authors prescribed dealt with the institution of marriage as it stood, not venturing outside the then current realm of possibility to approach the ultimate inequality. As for their place in history - meaning the eventual causal effect attributed to their works - that is much harder to say. Relying on the scholarship of others, it seems that they were relatively ineffective at shaping society. This little-heard story is an important part of the larger story of women’s liberation. These women, although not social innovators, nonetheless were already beginning to act as reformers digging around the roots of patriarchy in search for their solution.
It would take another generation of feminists, and arguably the French revolution, to effect a change in social, and political consciousness so great as to allow for a complete re-examination of the institution of marriage.
Solveig Smithback: "« New Hollywood » et la Nouvelle Vague: Une Analyse de Bonnie and Clyde et Pierrot le fou dans le Contexte des Années Soixante"
While Godard was innovating French cinema, Hollywood directors were staging a revolution. This “New Hollywood” cinema started with one film: Bonnie and Clyde. Released in 1967, directed by Arthur Penn, written by David Newman and Robert Benton, and produced by Warren Beatty, Bonnie and Clyde initiated a broad change in the American cinematic system. It represented the influences of the French New Wave cinema combined with American themes.
Because this film is so important in the 1960s American cinematic revolution, I wanted to analyze Bonnie and Clyde’s application of New Wave techniques in comparison to a Godard film with similar thematic elements: Pierrot le fou. Both films are treatments of the same theme and story: a genre-bending gangster film featuring a man and a woman caught up in a life of crime while enduring complex personal struggles internally and in their relationships. Each is also a representation of New Wave and New Hollywood cinema’s critique of the problems in government and society in France and America. In this paper, I analyze their respective French and American influences on technique, characters, and themes in their (1) representations of violence and its corresponding significance, (2) representations of the feminine and each couple’s complex relationship, and (3) the theme of escapism and its reference to the social culture of each film’s country.
Hayley Vatch: "Wilderness Ideologies, Economic Values, and the Boundary Waters Canoe Area in Minnesota"
The heated debates that arose between locals and “outsiders” culminated in 1978 with the congressional subcommittee hearings leading up to and the locally visible aftermath of the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness Act’s passage, which allowed motorboats to remain on a few lakes and further limited logging and mining in the area. However, some locals did not agree with the multiple use perspective, just as some “outsiders” did not entirely agree with the purely preservationist perspective. Individuals’ opinions of how the BWCA should be used and managed were largely shaped by individuals’ socioeconomic backgrounds and personal experiences with the area, as well as by their perception of the economic value of the area’s resources and offerings. The history of conflicts over the BWCA’s best use illustrates a larger question: should large areas of ecological and recreational value be preserved for all of America to enjoy, or should the people live closest to and whose livelihoods are derived from the area’s offerings be the ones to determine its best uses?
Madhuri Vijay: "The Effects of Sexist Humor on Men’s Tendency to be Sexually Aggressive"
JVanessa Weller: "L’aile humaine : une histoire de femme"
Chelsea Wirtz: " 'We Gotta Get Outta This Place:' Rock and Roll Preferences of Soldiers during the Vietnam War"
A different group that is rarely considered when analyzing the impact of music during this time is made up of the soldiers that were fighting the war overseas. These men and women had a very different musical experience than those back in the states, especially during the beginning years of U.S. involvement. The point of this paper is to find out why it was so different. In my research, I found a number of reasons that help to explain this disconnect. First, the soldiers simply did not have the same music available to them as was available in the states. This, coupled with many soldiers’ inclination to make their own music, necessitated preferential differences.
The larger, more complicated, facet of this question is how personal experiences shaped the minds of the soldiers and the civilians at home, which led to very different interpretations of the music of the time. These filters allowed the music to invoke very different feelings from the different groups, which would have impacted their respective preferences. In an effort to illustrate this more clearly, I have included lyric analysis of songs that were popular among the soldiers but saw only marginal chart success in the U.S., as well as analysis of a song that was tremendously popular in the states that was not received well among the soldiers.
